August 10, 2007 The Pump Handle 1Comment

In the last few days, we have all been in a state of shock over the situation in Utah. Like several of my colleagues, I have been praying for the trapped Utah miners and their families and friends. I have been tuning in to the press conferences with mine owner Bob Murray, and I have been refreshing CNN’s website over and over again to get the latest news on the rescue efforts.

Today, I walked passed a yellowed newspaper article from the Washington Post we hung on the side of a filing cabinet 20 months ago, in January 2006.

“Senators Say Budget Cuts Have Left Mines Unsafe” the headline proclaims, referring to a hearing on the Sago Mine disaster. I looked at the picture:



…and I thought to myself How long ago was this again?

20 months ago, Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA) held this device up and asked the same question I’m asking now: How much do these things cost? Why don’t we have these in all American mines?

I am so tired of hearing mining companies proclaim that they are doing everything they can to protect their miners, when the fact is that they simply are not. There is no reason why every mine in this country could not have tracking systems set up to allow them to track the location of every miner. There is no reason why we are digging holes into the ground to get to these men without knowing for sure that we are digging in the right place. It is beyond absurd at this point. It’s downright disgraceful.

In April 2006, two Australian miners were trapped underground for several days before their rescue. But the Australians weren’t telling the families they didn’t know where their men were. On the contrary, those families were able to send the men notes through a tube. The men were even sent iPods so they could listen to their favorite music while they awaited rescue.

And so I ask, again: what are we doing? Why have we still not learned our lesson? How many lives must be lost, and how many more days… or months… or years… must miners go to work not knowing if they’ll make it home again?

Note: Photo taken by Washington Post photographer Melina Mara.  Readers may click on the image to enlarge it.






One thought on “Why haven’t we learned our lesson?

  1. When disaster strikes the first thing that happens is someone says “it’s too early to play the blame game; let’s pray for the victims and their families and concentrate on rescue.”

    When the sea walls went down in New Orleans, Dick Cheney said “no one could have anticipated the failure of the levees.” Well, no one except National Geographic, Scientific American, The Smithsonian, and even the New Orleans Times Picayune, all of which had predicted the whole thing in exact detail years in advance.

    Why is it so hard to listen to evidence, to learn from experience? Why do we just keep saying; “Oh, I’m sure it will be all right” when the problem is plain as day?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.